Comic Strip of the Day Comic Strips Editorial cartooning

CSotD: Holiday Anecdotes and Antidotes

Christmas greetings from First Dog, who gets special placement today because he likes mince pies and fruitcake. I’ve made something of a tradition here of mocking cartoons that mock fruitcake, because it’s a grownup treat and so takes a lot of unwarranted abuse.

But here’s a strip from 2002 that explains what has happened to coffee, which is also a grownup treat and which, like fruitcake, has been moderated and modulated and sweetened and transformed into something popular but completely other.

The difference being that you can still get a cup of joe, but you really have to do some detective work to find dense, damp, dark fruitcake these days. It’s not impossible, but it’s a whole lot easier to find a cup of black coffee.

As First Dog notes, mince pies and fruitcake are adjacent and he’s right about marshmallows, too. I think Disney got hold of Christmas at some point, but there are still those of us with a more Fezziwig vision of the holiday.

Frazz always seems to take a long view of things, and here he traces the way Christmas has changed over the past century or two. As if often the case with Frazz, he left us something to Google, and James Lord Pierpont is the composer of Jingle Bells, which is not a Christmas carol and neither is Frosty the Snowman or Winter Wonderland.

And don’t make me bring out the Big Guns but not all songs about snow are about Christmas, which is a good thing for First Dog, since Christmas down his way is a summer holiday.

I’m not a grinch, but I got a chuckle out of this Daddy’s Home because I really can’t relate to the Christmas specials everyone gets so sentimental about.

It’s mostly an age thing: I was 14 when the first Peanuts special came on the air and I already had completely different voices locked in. I liked the Chuck Jones Grinch because it was true to the book, but most of the Claymation specials came after I was in high school and wasn’t in the right demographic anymore.

I mentioned Amahl and the Night Visitors to someone the other day and they had no idea what I was talking about, though it’s currently playing at the Lincoln Center. But that was appointment TV when I was a kid, back before taping and streaming, when you had to be in front of the set for Amahl, or Alastair Sim’s Christmas Carol or It’s a Wonderful Life.

That’s not just a Christmas thing, either: There’s something lost when you can watch Wizard of Oz anytime you want to, rather than having it be a special event.

(A Brief Discursion into Media)

Guy Body pre-emptively mourns the potential for Netflix to kill off the movie theatres, assuming it gets its grip on Warner Brothers, but notes that going to the movies hasn’t been an event in a long time, since people behave as if they were at home and were raised in a barn.

Deflocked then reminds us that watching at home isn’t the same, either, and seems unlikely to remain the same. Several of the streaming services have now begun tossing in ads and charging you extra to avoid them, which seems like a bait-and-switch scam, given that a lot of us stopped watching movies on broadcast TV because of the interruptions.

I pay for a video package but not for a bunch of add-on streamers, so aside from Turner Classics, I’m at the mercy of whoever thinks I’m not paying enough. So I’m on the “lots of monkeys” plan.

Which brings us to this

Juxtaposition of the Day

There used to be long arguments about which college football team was Number One. It had a lot to do with who had beaten whom and who had beaten them and so forth, such that when the announcer at a game would let us know Miami had beaten Southern Cal, we’d start chanting “We’re Number One!” because we’d beaten Michigan which had beaten Miami which had just beaten Southern Cal.

Now people chant “We’re Number One” even if, by logic, they’re number 147, and the arguments are no longer about football games but about rankings and playoffs. It’s gone from a lively argument among sports fans to a bunch of squabbling among accountants.

Football is not longer the point. The point is to create a new tournament that can’t resolve the arguments but provides streamers with another chance to charge us extra for the no-monkeys level of service.

Like a lot of games, football was more fun before the grown-ups stepped in and organized it.

Baby Blues surprised me this morning because I’ve seen a bunch of cartoons complaining about the needles dropping off Christmas trees, which is what you get if you buy a tree that was cut last month at the other end of the continent.

The solution is to buy local, whether that means cutting your own or buying from the scout troop. If you don’t know the source, at least run a thumb and finger down a branch to see if the needles fall off.

“Sappy” is a good thing. It means you can leave it up until Valentine’s Day.

This is not far off the mark. I get a couple of cards each year, including some from cartoonists, which not only have a personal touch to begin with but remind me of my father, who drew a card each year.

But the days when you could string the cards across your mantle seem largely over, and while Earl seems a bit grim in pointing it out, yes, a lot of that generation is gone. But not quite forgotten.

PSA: Blue Is Not A Permanent Color

The winter solstice is the darkest day of the year, but that means there will now be more light each day. Each year on this date, I repost a piece I wrote for people who may be feeling bluesy about now.

If you don’t need it, perhaps you’ll want to pass it on to someone who does.

Mike Peterson has posted his "Comic Strip of the Day" column every day since 2010. His opinions are his own, but we welcome comments either agreeing or in opposition.

Previous Post
Claremore Progress Comics Shuffle
Next Post
All Santa Histories Eventually Hit on Thomas Nast

Comments 27

  1. Two thoughts on today’s post:

    1. You actually get Turner Classic Movies without paying extra for it? In the Richmond, VA area Comcast (Xfinity) moved TCM (and only TCM) from basic cable to an esoteric sports channel (European soccer, cricket, at one time World Superbike and MotoGP, rodeos, etc.), which I refuse to subscribe to since they no longer carried the motorcycle racing channels. I miss TCM, but not that much.

    2. Maybe we’re not getting as many Christmas Cards anymore (we get two at our house) but we’re also no longer getting those damned “look how perfect our life is” newsletters that would come with the card. I used to get bombarded with them, until Christmas 1998. That was the (actually not terribly bad) year when I had a couple of noteworthy things go wrong (start with two motorcycle wrecks six weeks apart), that, with a bit of judicious editing I managed to turn into the most disastrous Christmas newsletter you’ve ever read. Which was sent to every family that had been sending me their missives. Christmas 1999 was marked by a complete absence of newsletters, and a marked decline in the number of cards received.

  2. I appreciate the Baby Blues’ Zoe stuck to the sappy tree riffing on the 1958 “The Fly”.

  3. Coffee shops or ’boutiques’ need express lanes for grumps who just want a plain coffee.

  4. It is so easy to have a coffee maker at home. I get coffee strong enough (but not too strong) in ten minutes. And it is a tad less expensive. Being old fashioned isn’t always a sin.

    1. Hard to do on a long road trip, otherwise you are right on the money.

  5. I love George’s solution to the Christmas Letter! Sounds like he killed a couple of birds with one stone. I actually enjoy the letters when they’re full of real news and personality–my favorite this year was from a friend who spent two pages describing what her cats were up to. It’s the braggarts who ruined them for the rest of us. People with perfect lives should know to keep it to themselves.

    Re: buying Christmas trees, your “buy local” advice only applies if you live somewhere evergreens are at least a little bit native. When our daughters were young, we enjoyed tromping out to a local Christmas tree farm to cut down our own. Aside from the joy of playing lumberjack, we assumed we were getting the best, freshest tree available. But they were light, and dried out fast, because we don’t get the sort of rain and weather they really need to thrive. It took us a long time to realize we got much better quality from the big commercial lot whose trees were shipped from Oregon and Washington that weighed three times as much and lasted three times as long.

    I’m also reminded of being a boy in the Black Hills of South Dakota, when my Uncle Cal could get a permit from the Forest Service to tromp out into the snow and cut down any tree he wanted. I nearly froze to death one time; Uncle Cal was a deliberate tree chooser and my boots filled up with snow. It was great.

    If you didn’t get my card yet, it’s on the way.

  6. The seasonal vs. Christmas debate for songs is kind of a lost battle, just because of “Jingle Bells,” “Winter Wonderland,” and “Frosty.” I’m fine with it just because it adds variety, otherwise we get eighty-nine versions of the same tired dozen Christmas standards that aren’t based on ancient English or Latin carols. What roils me is the adoption sometime in the nineties of the summer ’49 hit (from “Neptune’s Daughter,” a movie set in California about a South American soccer team!) of “Baby, It’s Cold Outside” (aka the Cosby song) which promotes smoking, drinking and rohypnol.

    Somehow (at least in my experience; it may have changed over the past decade) holiday radio has skipped both the Trade Winds’ “New York’s a Lonely Town,” where everything’s covered in snow (including the subject’s surf board) and there are jangling sleigh bells throughout, and Anne Murray’s “Snowbird,” with its winter setting. The former was issued in January of ’65, the latter in February of ’70 (though it didn’t chart till July), so it isn’t like they weren’t intended to be seasonal. If we include songs about the cold, “I Am a Rock,” “Hazy Shade of Winter,” “California Dreamin’,” “It’s Now Winter’s Day,” “Urge for Going” (either Tom Rush’s or Joni Mitchell’s version–or both) and the Choir’s “It’s Cold Outside” are gloomy autumn-turning-to-winter songs I’d include on my playlist. On the other hand, “December ’63 (Oh What a Night)” is a Christmas/winter song like “Die Hard” is a Christmas movie. (I’m sure if I thought about it, I could come up with plenty of others you don’t hear on holiday radio.) My point is, 21st-century radio programmers are a lazy lot who wouldn’t know appropriate seasonal records which don’t include the word “Christmas” in them.

    1. “Baby It’s Cold Outside” is about the games people had to play back when women weren’t supposed to enjoy — much less want — sexual relations. The lady in that song (who wrote it and performed it with her husband) was joking about the phony fastidiousness of the age. Which is still here, so it’s best to let the song be history, and yet we should remember that there was such a time.

      1. These days people mostly insists the song is about rape, and that the woman really really did not want to stay in spite of the cold.

        Whatever. Playful or not it’s a dumb song.

    2. Somehow I never hear “Christmas in Prison” by John Prine.

      “It was Christmas in prison
      And the food was real good
      We had turkey and pistols
      Carved out of wood”

      Festive!

      1. Christmas in jail
        Christmas in jail
        Wore my shoes out pacin’ the floor
        Got rocks i my head
        I wish I were dead
        Ain’t gonna drink and drive no more.
        Merry Christmas!

        Local oldies show The Magic Time-Warp Show has played that every Saturday in December. You can listen to it here: https://spinitron.com/KNON/pl/21704322/Magic-Time-Warp

    3. I love Mary Black’s version of Urge For Going.

  7. It’s common knowledge that John Prine was a huge fan of Christmas and that I’m a huge fan of John Prine. Two songs I can’t get through the season without are Bill Monroe’s “Christmas Times A Coming” and Hag’s “If We Make Through December”, but they don’t get played on the radio around here.

  8. C’mon, we all know “How the Grinch Stole Christmas” cartoon is great because of the triumvirate of Boris Karloff, Thurl Ravenscroft, and Chuck Jones.

    Not to dis the Seuss book, it was the first tome I ever borrowed from the library. 🙂

    1. There’s a lot to be said about Chuck Jones’ adaptation, but it starts with him understanding the book, which explains how he assembled that immortal cast. I got the book the year it was published, so I knew it well, and, by golly, his voices matched mine. And I think they matched Dr. Seuss’s vision as well.

      Which is to say that his successful adaptation is the result of his reading the book and getting it and finding a way to turn it into a video. Which is why Chuck Jones was such a genius!

  9. Fun fact: “Frosty the Snowman” is based on an urban legend that allegedly took place in Armonk, NY, in the late 1930s….or some say White Plains.

  10. quickly notable these are all from the family friendly/boring end of the medium

  11. There’s a lot to unpack with today’s selection, so I’ll just go down the list:

    Fruitcake and mincemeat pie are the sort of thing people mock simply because they’ve never had the real thing. Indeed, the whole “eww, fruitcake” thing is so overplayed it’s not worth mentioning.

    I’m not bothered by the fact that Holiday tradition has changed over the centuries (I mean, EVERYthing changes to some degree or other given enough time. Evolution isn’t just for living things!) but rather the good ol’ crass commercialism that came with the 20th century. Much ink has already been spilled over the transition of Christmas being a time of celebration to SPEND SPEND SPEND so I’ll leave it at that.

    I also agree that most Christmas TV specials don’t really do it for me, but they’re inoffensive enough.

    Streaming really has become Cable 2.0, the initial “no ads” appeal vanished a long time ago. To be fair, cable wasn’t supposed to have ads either, since it was something you paid for (and often rather a lot)
    But there’s no stopping corporate greed.

    Movies and TV did lose some of their charm once “you can watch anytime” became a thing. Ironically, I find myself watching movies & TV far less these days because 1. there’s really not much I want to see and 2. there’s no FOMO. For the most part, if it’s something I really want I’ll buy it on DVD/Bluray.

    One thing I really do miss is putting up the tree. I live alone so what’s the point? I also have nowhere to store it the other 11 months of the year. Well, unless I get a real tree which my family never did.

    My parents used to get a TON of cards, from friends and family and church folk, even from coworkers.
    They used to display them in the venetian blinds in the dining room. But yep, those days are long gone.

    And speaking of days, I am sooooo glad they’ll start getting longer again from here out.

  12. It is no longer possible to buy Cross and Blackwell mincemeat with rum and brandy in the U.S. Possible to find (but difficult) are currant raisins for dark fruitcake. At least candied lemon peel slices can still be gotten, but being imported from Italy they are now extra costly. I have not bothered to make any holiday treats this year, but will admit to a craving for sausage rolls. It will pass.

  13. There is still Magoo’s Christmas Carol. I love indulging in variations of that story, and am happy to have found a narration by Tim Curry which i look forward to beginning.

    This year we discovered that by draping colored fairy lights over a glass lamp we and the neighbors can enjoy a result reminiscent of Avatar night jungle plants. Easier than a tree and still fun.

  14. Living not that far from First Dog, we just went through our longest day.

    It seems an American thing to mock fruitcake and I don’t understand that at all. In my family we like to have lots of glacé cherries in our cake mixture.

    We have a living Xmas tree that lives on our balcony the rest of the year. Not bonsai, it’s about a metre tall, a Norfolk pine. It only has about twelve long straggly branches though, so might not suit all tastes.

    Is Fairytale of New York a popular Xmas tune in the USA?

    1. Fairytale of New York isn’t an established Christmas tune in the US as far as I know—I had never heard it until it turned up on a Pogues greatest hits CD that I got. It wasn’t until years after that that I learned it was a Christmas classic in the UK—which seems weird, isn’t kind of depressing?

      1. Kind of depressing? It is, but then so is Xmas to a lot of people! It’s my Australian wife’s favourite. For me, nothing surpasses The Ronettes singing Sleigh Ride.

  15. Stevie Wonder’s “Smile Please” is a Winter Solstice song: “There are brighter days ahead.”

  16. Having worked retail back in the day and not really being a holiday person to begin with, I wish I could just slip into a coma from mid-November through late-February, bypassing the whole holiday season(s). I really, really hate this time of the year.

  17. The Trailer Park Boys Christmas Special, (which is available on Netflix) is unlike anything you’ve ever seen before. Profane and disgraceful, but with an honestly uplifting message, if you’re not too picky about what can or can’t be uplifting.

  18. And a very merry Feast of Sol Invictus to you and yours. Nothing says the holidays like being baptized in bull’s blood.

Comments are closed.

Search

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get a daily recap of the news posted each day.