See All Topics

Home / Section: Editorial cartooning

CSotD: Whose karma is it, anyway?

Perhaps the best way to lead off this topic is to direct you to Clay Jones’ site, where he shares various sketches and ponders aloud how to handle the President’s Covid diagnosis.

 

I don’t particularly care for the somewhat celebratory cartoon he eventually came up with, but he explains his feelings in greater depth in the accompanying essay to this one, and, while I firmly believe cartoons must stand alone, it provides a chance to peek behind the curtain on an occasion when we all need to not only analyze how various cartoonists got to where they landed, but do some looking inward as well.

I don’t wish Donald Trump harm. I’m not even going to say he deserved this. Honestly, it shouldn’t surprise anyone he caught it with the way he approached it. He exercised zero caution. Protect America? He couldn’t protect himself. He couldn’t protect his family. Donald Trump testing positive isn’t as much karma as it was inevitable.

And he’s right that it isn’t “karma.” Karma happens after you’re dead.

It may be “ironic,” but the world is not inherently moral, or, at least, not this one.

I think Jones’ term is closest to appropriate: “Inevitable.”

Hence this

Juxtaposition of the Day

(Rob Rogers – AMS)

 

(Greg Kearney – Ind.)

I like both expressions here, because it’s not simply that Trump failed to exercise proper caution but that he made rejecting that caution part of the re-election campaign he launched as soon as he took office.

Rogers walks a tightrope here, using a bit of humor but not going for what would be a distasteful belly-laugh over it, but I think Kearney edges him out by using whimsical graphics that combine for a completely grim cartoon.

Our responses might be similar in the aftermath of a drunk-driving accident, differing depending on whether it’s someone who inadvertently had too much at an office party versus someone who repeatedly gets sloshed and drives home anyway.

We don’t have to like ourselves for responding that way, but we do, and how we handle that fact is what is now on the table.

The term “virtue signaling” is being used a lot in social media, mostly to criticize people who have been anti-Trump but now say we should wish him a safe recovery.

It feels to me like a kind of jiu-jitsu, in which you virtue signal by announcing that other people are virtue signaling, but not you, by golly.

We should, indeed, admire you for the way in which you avoid virtue signaling!

 

Dana Summers (Tribune) provides an example: By assuming he can see into the hearts of Democrats, he lets us know he’s not like them.

 

By contrast, Chris Britt (Creators) makes a point of the degree to which Trump flouted good sense, and, while Jones was more celebratory that I would have liked, I think Britt piles on way too much for the moment.

Your mileage certainly may vary.

 

Meanwhile, Kal Kallaugher (AMS) simply lays it out, making roughly the same point as Rogers and Kearney but with no humor to lighten the matter. He’s not citing karma, which suggests a moral judgment, but, rather, hubris, the pride that, in Greek tragedy, brings great men to grief, in a combination of pity and terror.

At which point I went off to find Aristotle’s half-remembered requirements for tragedy and stumbled upon this excellent encyclopedia entry which I strongly recommend for those who were not lashed to Greek oars in college.

It includes Sir Philip Sidney’s remark about “high and excellent tragedy, that…with stirring the affects of admiration and commiseration teacheth the uncertainty of this world and upon how weak foundations gilden roofs are builded.”

Bottom line: If you can’t summon pity for the way Oedipus and Jocasta innocently stumbled into their star-crossed marriage, you won’t be able to feel the terror of feeling it could happen to you.

And, if you think it can’t happen to you, well, Grasshopper, that’s a bit of internal virtue signaling.

Better, I think, to take the lesson and learn from it, as seen in this

 

Juxtaposition of the Day #2

(David Horsey – Seattle Times)

 

(Deb Milbrath – Ind)

 I particularly like Horsey’s depiction of a hardscrabble, blue-collar couple because that’s who I grew up with, and plain-spoken can also be well-reasoned. Let’s hope there are more like him out there, who may feel culturally bound to one position but who are thinking things through and will, in the end, behave with common sense.

Meanwhile, Milbrath comes from a different, though related, viewpoint, suggesting adjustments for those who may be struggling a bit more with the news and predicting that they may not find it necessary to have a complete change of political loyalties in order to come into alignment with sensible behavior.

Her piece could also have been juxtaposed with Britt’s — echoing his frustration with months of denial and poppycock, but adding an ever-so-slight hint of compassion to her criticism.

 

Finally, Martyn Turner (Irish Times) offers a view I almost began with, because, rather than, like Jones, showing how cartoonists might struggle with the news, he offers a more broad-based perspective on how we’re all struggling.

There are certainly enough opinions on social media to cover the spectrum he lays out, from the aforementioned virtue signaling of the schadenfreude crowd to conspiracy theories that Trump is faking it to avoid the next debate or perhaps the entire election, to cynical suggestions that he’s much sicker than the White House is letting on.

To that last, I’d note that, while we’re not in 25th Amendment territory now, the public was not told how badly Reagan was injured in that assassination attempt, nor the seriousness of Ike’s heart attack, nor the extent of damage in Wilson’s stroke, and, for that matter, Grover Cleveland had a malignant tumor, and much of his upper jaw, removed without telling the public at all.

None of which proves a damn thing about Donald Trump. Stay tuned to the news.

Meanwhile, bear in mind that his disease has nothing to do with karma.

But your response might.

 

Community Comments

#1 Janet Ober
October/3/2020
@ 9:36 am

It is not only that Trump denied the science but that he actively made decisions that harmed and killed people for his own benefit. From dismantling the pandemic team, to refusing masks offered by WHO, to wasting money buying up his pet drug so those with lupus couldn’t get it, to putting Jared in charge of PPE, to refusing to help cities because mayors didn’t agree with him. Trump is directly responsible for suffering and deaths. Not all of them, but especially because it was deliberate, even a few would be too many. I support Britt’s take completely.

#2 phil von neupert
October/3/2020
@ 12:19 pm

Love Horsey’s cartoon. Now that Trump has the virus, his supporters can be paranoid about that, instead of “gum-mint” mask mandates.

#3 Ronnald Mills
October/3/2020
@ 7:44 pm

I wonder if Brit knows that trump did not ever actually make that comment about injecting bleach. He was talking to A
scientist who pointed out that bleach would kill the corona virus on surfaces. Is a very delicate virus.
Go watch the footage of the actual conversation.

#4 Christopher Ward
October/4/2020
@ 12:07 am

So, this is coming from someone who voted for Trump in ’16 because I felt that his stated goals were more aligned with mine than Clinton’s were.

I hope that he recovers. And I hope that he learns something from this, though I doubt he will. But I really hope that being hospitalized in October will put the election out of his reach.

#5 Bill Goodr
October/4/2020
@ 9:28 am

I can honestly say that I’m not happy Trump has COVID, nor do I wish him ill. That being said, it does feel “correct,” like the world is as it should be.

#6 Matt Thompson
October/4/2020
@ 2:50 pm

Not to be argumentative, but the description or understanding (in this article) of what ‘Karma’ really is, is in error. Karma is, essentially, “action”. That is it’s literal meaning in Sanskrit. It is the never ending law of sequence and consequence. It doesn’t just occur after death. We are making Karma, for good or ill, by our own personal standards, every minute of every day. If President Trump has the coronavirus it is his Karma. If he never got it, that is also his Karma. Likewise, it is the Karma of each country, indeed the whole world, to have to go through this pandemic. It is the American people’s Karma to have Mr Trump as their president. It is his Karma to be the President of America, and so on and so forth. Karma is a completely impersonal law (according to the foundational Hindu philosophy), and has nothing to do with revenge either. There is much more to it than this, of course, but I just thought I’d give an explanation of a term that is widely used these days.

#7 Kathy Regan
October/5/2020
@ 4:51 pm

I was wondering when someone would explain what Karma is. I thought of doing so myself but most people don’t want to hear that they are responsible for their own actions.

#8 Hank Gillette
October/6/2020
@ 8:16 am

“And then I see the disinfectant, where it knocks it out in one minute. And is there a way we can do something like that, by injection inside or almost a cleaning, because you see it gets in the lungs and it does a tremendous number on the lungs, so it’d be interesting to check that, so that you’re going to have to use medical doctors with, but it sounds interesting to me.”

The best you can say is that he did not specifically say bleach, but disinfectant. He did say injection though.

#9 Phil Maish
October/6/2020
@ 11:39 am

It’s not pleasure I feel; more like grim satisfaction. I’d call this situation Cosmic Justice. He himself took plenty of precautions; he and his staff were tested constantly, so he could be assured he was surrounded by the uninfected, like human shields. At the same time he was exhorting his fans to eschew masks and crowd together at his rallies, he was waaay up on stage, separated from his “disgusting” supporters. He thought that would be enough. He thought wrong.

Like Michael Che, I wish him a lengthy recovery. I hope he has some lasting damage from the disease, but I certainly don’t want him to die. He needs to be defeated, disgraced. He has court dates to keep. Those prison sentences aren’t going to serve themselves! He owes us.

#10 Keith Brown
October/7/2020
@ 8:06 am

George Bush and Dick Cheney lied us in to a war that killed thousands and thousands. The only consequence they suffered was to retire peacefully and enjoy their riches. If Trump loses, does anyone really expect for him to be held accountable in any appreciable way?

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.