See All Topics

Home / Section: Magazine cartoons

Judging 2009’s New Yorker cartoonists

The Village Voice’s Brian Parks has ranked last year’s best New Yorker cartoonists. The article doesn’t specify the judging criteria. Top ranking cartoonists included: Paul North, John O’Brien, Alex Gregory, Drew Dernavich and Danny Shanahan. Cartoon editor Bob Mankoff landed at #7.

Community Comments

#1 Rick Ellis
January/14/2010
@ 1:20 pm

“The article doesnâ??t specify the judging criteria.”

“I liked the kitty.”
Mr. Elinoff to Elaine in Sienfield

#2 Shannon Wheeler
January/14/2010
@ 3:09 pm

Based on a minimum of 10 appearances, thank you very much (I had 5).

#3 Rich Diesslin
January/15/2010
@ 12:21 am

I think while the criteria is subjective it’s clear what it is and it’s quite funny in and of itself. Maybe next year Shannon! ;)

#4 Kevin Moore
January/15/2010
@ 12:38 am

You should have had many more appearances, Shannon. Your rejects are hilarious.

#5 Jeff Darcy
January/15/2010
@ 12:05 pm

How ’bout the VOICE ranking the top ten cartoon features they and other alternatives axed to save money.

#6 Peter Plum
July/11/2010
@ 11:57 am

Now we need a list of the most rejected New Yorker cartoonists of all time. By my count, over 20,000 times.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.